Sithious wrote:
Ahh, but do you have pictures of Elves with gravity defying cloaks billowing out or a rider with a cloak as wrinkled as Thranduil's seams to be? Gandalfs cloak seams to behave itself pretty good and remain flat, I know it is of different material, but the cloaks on elven Cav models just always flapping around like a wounded Legolas.
Strictly speaking, Gandalf isn't wearing his cloak while riding that horse, just his robes. It would be weird if his robes were to billow like Thranduil's cloak, because then audiences would need to become acquainted with Mr. Mckellen's backside, and while I'm sure we all honour his status, I don't think any of us are quite ready to make that commitment yet.