LOL, I voted for "other" as well. Too many options for a poll!

Actually, how about Dwarves?

By the book, just the High Men and Noldor and possibly some others that do look huge. All orc kind should be downgraded a level, you throw your Uruks in the bin and orcs become Uruks and Goblns orcs, there should not be a noticable difference between orc and goblin as thats just a film thing, goblins are orcs.

You have no have Mr. Average at S3 or the important D6 will become almost worthless.

I know everybody loves their tough Dwarves, but if Men are S4, Dwarves are S3 for sure. Gimli made a point at Helm's Deep that the Men looked too big for him to handle, but the Orcs (including Uruks) were not. If Men are S3, by rights Dwarves and Orcs should be S2 and Hobbits and Goblins S1...but the way the power structure of the rules are it's really hard to justify all but the weakest (such as Hobbits and Goblins) going below S3, which makes for very little differentiation.

Dwarves do start at D4 however (rather than D3), and I had a special rule in mind for them:

Stubborn: a Dwarf is not pushed back even if he loses a fight, unless he is outnumbered or his opponent is S6 or higher. He can still be trapped, however. I haven't worked out the exact wording, but the idea was, he can only be pushed back if the number of dice rolled against him is greater than the number he rolls, ie: one Dwarf against an Orc won't be pushed back; one Dwarf against an Orc + spear backup will be; one Dwarf that is shielding against an Orc + spear backup won't be...etc.

I had some others in mind as well.

No really are you kidding, Dwarves are stonger than men...

Okey, well I don´t remember the books so well anymore, but really Dwarves were stronger than men both physically and mentally, although they were depicted as whimps in the Hobbit I do recall Gimli being quite a powerful warrior...? or is the Peter Jackson vision playing tricks with me?

of course dwarves are fairly strong. They normally go around wearing very heavy armour/ an large array of axes for throwing/2 handed ones/normal ones etc.

All other men, and even most numenorians in the 3rd age would still be weaker than an elf or dwarf in the 3rd age but there is more of them.

Personally i would vote for dwarves, uruks, noldor and elite men as being strength 4. But my view of what uruks are seem to differ to yours. I believe uruks are the half me/half orc mix while i think that you think of uruks as big orcs

Other forces in Saruman's armies, and under his command in the Shire, are also speculated in the novel to be hybrids of Orcs and Men. However, these individuals, called "half-orcs" and "goblin-men" in The Two Towers, were sallow-skinned, squint-eyed, and as tall as Men while the Uruk-hai were darker and not as tall. Another distinction was in soldiering ability; Saruman's Uruk-hai's discipline compared very favorably to Orcs of Mordor and Moria, but his half-Orcs showed no more competence than common ruffians. These are also never described simply as Orcs, as the Uruk-hai frequently are. An account of the first Battle of the Fords of Isen in Unfinished Tales (part of Tolkien's hitherto unpublished writings) apparently treats Uruk-hai and "orc-men" separately.