Quote:
...but for balance, flare, storyline there has to be a trigger to make the switch.
I think I was confused by this, it doesn't sound like there's a trigger:
Quote:
My profile for Beorn allows him to switch into Bear Form at will...
Maybe you meant the opposite? FWIW, I think Beorn's profile and points are good. Grimbeorn though is costed only for his human stat line and it doesn't take into account his bear stats. And he can make a Courage roll easily, so why wouldn't he do it on the first turn? Then you have a 65 point model better than a cave troll.
Quote:
You are right about the Bodyguard rule, but they have to nominate one of the Hero's. Be it Beorn or his son Grimbeorn.
Maybe if they were both on the field...but that doesn't seem likely if they are just flavour like Woses. The bodyguard rule is basically a 2 point rule (compare RRG with something equivalent that doesn't have bodyguard). Beorn has a standfast of 12" and that's presumably factored into his cost. But if he's the nominated hero, standfast doesn't matter. When he's alive, all the warriors pass courage automatically, he might as well have no standfast at all. If he's dead, no standfast nor bodyguard rule. So points are being spent, either in the warrior or hero profile, that are wasted. IMHO you should pick one or the other rule.
Quote:
You mentioned the Rohan Royal Guard as your example, but they are a base of 10points and have a 1point higher Defence than my rendition of the Warrior Beornling which are a base of 8points.
Right. Customarily that +1D = 1 point, so your Beornings should be 9 points.
Quote:
As for every House Rule: Like it or Leave it. Its all about having fun.
? Are you saying you don't want feedback? Or only positive feedback?