SouthernDunedain wrote:
its personal preference what you use. an easier way to deal with cavalry, (i find) is to just form a shield wall with spear support and pikes if you have them. And considering you have Fountain guard, there isnt evil cavalry that is F4 that the armies you play have access to. I'd say your top list is better. Deploy the FG first line, CG second line and shoot the cav as it comes towards you. Use the normal spears to protect your flank.
Okay, I'll start calculating:
Wood elves are def 3 and strenght 3
Uruks are def 5-6 and strength 4
Goblins are def 4-5 and strength 3
High Elves are def 5-6 and strength 3
I'll hit wood elves on a 4+, and they'll hit both Minas tirith warriors and fountain guards (all with shields) on a 6+. They'll win the fights on draws.
I'll hit uruks on a 5 or 6, and they'll hit my minas tiriths on a 5+, but the fountain guards on a 6+. It's either contest with GotFC or a win for them with the normal ones on a draw
I'll hit the goblins on a 5+, and they'll hit both my Minas tiriths and Fountain guards on a 6+. I'll win the fights
I'll hit the High Elves on a 5 or 6+, and they'll hit both my MT warriors and GotFC on a 6+. They'll win fights
So, that means I should use GotFC only against uruks, as they're the only enemies with a contestable fight and S4. Isn't it better to just take D6 troops?